Card Shack, Sports Cards

Highlights

• ✨Vibe

  "great cards ,friendly service very satisfied"

  — Henry Berman

• 📚Selection

  "Very big with wife selection of cards and packs"

  — Tyler Chindananta

• 🧠Staff

  "Great selection! Super helpful staff. Highly recommend."

  — Justin Rimbert

• 💵Prices

  "Great shop!!! Top notch inventory, service, and prices."

  — Brian Britton

About this shop

Card Shack, Sports Cards is a brick-and-mortar trading card shop in Lynbrook, New York. The shop carries Pokémon, Yu-Gi-Oh!, Sports Cards. Customer reviews give Card Shack, Sports Cards a 4.5-star average across 146 ratings. Reviewers specifically mention grading, vintage, singles, expert staff. Hours, phone, directions, and recent reviews are below — call ahead to confirm stock for the cards or sealed product you're looking for.

Card shop in Lynbrook, NY · part of our directory of trading card stores across New York.

Map

Hours

• Nick Scumaci ★★★★★

  Great shop! The staff is friendly and knowledgeable. The selection is always top of the line and accessible at all price points. Highly recommended for anyone who collects sports cards/memorabilia!

  3 months ago

• Liam Mongan ★★★★★

  Lots of options for all sports, solid deals, and tons of great cards. Always my go to when I wanna buy some Topps. Also good to note that the staff is always polite and helpful and will tell you anything you need to know.

  5 months ago

• Tony ★

  Went in here to trade over $100 worth of sports cards. The guy told me pass on everything. Which was fine, weird but fine. Then I realized I had 3 big ones left i was holding on to. I showed the lesser of the 3 saving the best one I had for last. He put them aside and then asked to see the last one . “ I said no, can’t show you all my cards I’ll show you the last one once you give me a price on the other 2”. Then simultaneously has says “I’ll pass on these to “ As if to Punish me. All the while ( Steve”/Stevie/Owner) is Millingering around, never says hello or anything to me. I hesitantly show

  8 months ago

• Tim Nelson ★★★★★

  Nick, the sales representative was very professional and courteous called many places just to get information and everybody seem like I was bothering them. Nick was very Patient And kind of being new in the card business I just want a general information again very helpful thanks, Nick

  8 months ago

• Tim Wall ★★★★★

  Always a great experience with nick and the staff. They are always super nice to my kids and make the process go smoothly. Highly recommend.

  5 months ago

• christina f ★★★★★

  Always a pleasant experience. Friendly staff. Lots of inventory and plenty of options for all budgets.

  3 months ago

• Eric H ★★★★★

  What a great collectables store . Great display cases with all sorts of cards to collect from new to old and every type of sport or trading card game. Had a very good selection of collection accessories like card protectors. Staff who helped me was super friendly and very helpful. I was very impressed and I can't wait to bring my kids in to look and talk about what we are collecting next! Thank you so much !

  3 years ago

• Melissa Compson ★★★★★

  Card Shack is an amazing establishment! Great cards, helpful staff and always a fun visit!

  3 months ago