City Cards & Collectibles

Highlights

• ✨Vibe

  "Good cards, fair priced. Stafff very friendly"

  — Edison Tan

• 📚Selection

  "Great store great selection great customer service"

  — Franco R

• 🧠Staff

  "Great Store Helpful Service For Any Cards"

  — Timothy Willis

• 💵Prices

  "Good cards, fair priced. Stafff very friendly"

  — Edison Tan

About this shop

City Cards & Collectibles is a brick-and-mortar trading card shop in Staten Island, New York. The shop carries Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering, Sports Cards. Customer reviews give City Cards & Collectibles a 4.4-star average across 149 ratings. Reviewers specifically mention grading, vintage, singles, buylist. Hours, phone, directions, and recent reviews are below — call ahead to confirm stock for the cards or sealed product you're looking for.

Card shop in Staten Island, NY · part of our directory of trading card stores across New York.

Map

Hours

• World's Fair ★★★★★

  Staten Island has always had an awful reputation for price gouging when it comes to sports cards and collectibles. Thankfully City Cards is the long awaited exception to this rule. Every single time I have made numerous purchases at Triple C’s I have not paid full price. I have always been taken care of and I never feel buyers remorse like I often do at other retailers. Joe always goes out of his way to make some kind of discount or offering to take money off his already reasonable marked prices. Often times you find store owners obsessing over certain hot products but Joe always prices fairl

  7 months ago

• Peter Ragone ★★★★★

  Walked into City Cards & Collectibles admittedly not knowing much about the cards I was looking to buy as a gift. Brandon was understanding and took the time to explain what I was looking at and what might be the best purchase for me. Extremely friendly and prices were great in comparison to other collectible stores in the area. Definitely worth stopping in if you're in the market for cards/collectibles!

  3 months ago

• JD ★★★★★

  I’m more than happy for what I buy here especially for the price. I really like the fact that I don’t live that far away from this place, definitely my go to spot now. The staff are very nice and they were able to help me with some questions I had about NFL hobby boxes, I will definitely be coming back to buy some more

  8 months ago

• Christian ★

  Very unprofessional service with a kid looking up the lowest sale he sees from eBay out of all places. They tried to price match my /10 card that is worth over $100 with a $20 card that is nothing like it. Would not recommend

  3 months ago

• CHILL328GREE19 ★★★★★

  The shop was clean and an awesome experience all around. Brendan was the one who helped me and he was awesome and very helpful! Highly recommend if you’re into sports/TCG cards, come to the shop and check it out!

  4 months ago

• Pl Rnr ★★★★★

  Walked in and was immediately greeted by Brandon. He talked me and my kid through some of the cards they had. Very nice place and super organized. Didn't rush us through anything. Would recommend to all. Thanks so much!

  4 months ago

• Wellington Won ★★★★★

  Great service and wonderful selection of new and older carslds.. Super friendly and helpful. Brandon is A++. Must stop in Staten Island.

  3 months ago

• Emilio Pena ★★★★★

  Had a great buying experience with these guys. Real cool owner and was a great help in making my purchasing experience. He even gifted me a free pack. Amazing place will def come again.

  a year ago