Game On!!

Highlights

• 📚Selection

  "Although expensive, it’s always best to support your local card shops. Giving it any less than a 5 star would seem rude. They have great selection, great knowledge of the product they deal with. Would love to work here some day. Seems like a dream come true."

  — sam gallo

• 🧠Staff

  "Always find some good stuff here. Weather it's sports cards or autographed memorabilia. To have a nice card shop like this locally is a blessing. Great owner and staff. Its one of a very few go to places in the area."

  — Jamie Raffa

• 💵Prices

  "This place was great. Prices on hobby boxes and retail were right on pair with Dave and adams if not a little cheaper. The owner spent the time helping me pick out what football cards to start getting into as I am just getting back into the hobby."

  — Ryan Einhiple

About this shop

Game On!! is a brick-and-mortar trading card shop in Rochester, New York. The shop carries Sports Cards. Customer reviews give Game On!! a 4.4-star average across 41 ratings. Reviewers specifically mention vintage, singles, owner-run. Hours, phone, directions, and recent reviews are below — call ahead to confirm stock for the cards or sealed product you're looking for.

Card shop in Rochester, NY · part of our directory of trading card stores across New York.

Map

Hours

• Courtney Seth ★★★★★

  Nice out of the way collector's store. Traded a card at a reasonable price, have decent cards for display and many new types of boxes of cards. Nice place to bring kids new to collecting since there are boxes of cheap cards they can look through! Also, can buy storage boxes for cheap.

  a month ago

• Jamie Raffa ★★★★★

  Always find some good stuff here. Weather it's sports cards or autographed memorabilia. To have a nice card shop like this locally is a blessing. Great owner and staff. Its one of a very few go to places in the area.

  6 months ago

• Old timer ★

  Shop sucks, John’s a careless owner and almost lost some of my personal items back in the day and thought it was funny. Haven’t been back since an never will.

  4 months ago

• DJ2_Cards ★★★★★

  I'm not sure if it's a good or bad thing to have such an awesome card shop like this so close to my house. After being away from the hobby for over 30 years, I returned to see that most of the shops I grew to love are gone or aren't nearly what they used to be. Game On has a great selection of cards and is one of the few (if not only) shops that has modern and vintage singles and is willing to do trades with you. John is a great guy and runs a very clean and organized shop. It's always a pleasure to stop in and see what's new or to pick up the supplies that I need. I wish more card shops took

  a year ago

• Joseph Rogers ★

  I am changing my review from 5 stars to 1 star. I initially had a good experience and left a 5 star review afterwards and tried them a few more times. The original person I dealt with was great (did not get his name) but since then have not had a great experience. I've been purchasing football card boxes here - usual price is around $50 (can be purchased online for around $35-$40). I went in last week and was charged $77 for the same box. I was in a rush and really wasn't paying attention until I got home and realized. Checked pricing to see if anything changed and they are still selling for

  Edited 4 years ago

• sam gallo ★★★★★

  Although expensive, it’s always best to support your local card shops. Giving it any less than a 5 star would seem rude. They have great selection, great knowledge of the product they deal with. Would love to work here some day. Seems like a dream come true.

  3 years ago

• Matthew Koerner ★★★★★

  Best card shop in Rochester. Most places will make you feel uncomfortable by just being present. They got all types of memorabilia as well, and trades aren't out of the question... John (the owner, I believe) loves his line of work, so dealing with him is nice. Other than service, you can find the cards you need there, maybe a jersey... but regardless, best shop in Rochester.

  5 years ago

• Ryan Einhiple ★★★★★

  This place was great. Prices on hobby boxes and retail were right on pair with Dave and adams if not a little cheaper. The owner spent the time helping me pick out what football cards to start getting into as I am just getting back into the hobby.

  4 years ago