Mid Island Collectibles

Highlights

• ✨Vibe

  "This place is wonderful! Amazing Prices! Family Friendly! Pokemon, Comics, and Magic Oh My! ❤️"

  — Akarui Kaze

• 📚Selection

  "I Walked into mid island collectibles not having any expectation.. I was significantly impressed with their game options and customer service. Mark was very welcoming the moment i walked in. Seems to be genuine individuals working there and they have a LARGE selection of games, Knick nacks and cards.."

  — Kevin Hernandez

• 🧠Staff

  "Great business with the Pokemon card merchants here!!! Will continue business. Must recommend!!!"

  — Darryl Menchan Jr

• 💵Prices

  "This place is wonderful! Amazing Prices! Family Friendly! Pokemon, Comics, and Magic Oh My! ❤️"

  — Akarui Kaze

About this shop

Mid Island Collectibles is a brick-and-mortar trading card shop in Hicksville, New York. The shop carries Pokémon. Customer reviews give Mid Island Collectibles a 5.0-star average across 21 ratings. Reviewers specifically mention kid-friendly, casual. Hours, phone, directions, and recent reviews are below — call ahead to confirm stock for the cards or sealed product you're looking for.

Card shop in Hicksville, NY · part of our directory of trading card stores across New York.

Map

Hours

• Kevin Hernandez ★★★★★

  I Walked into mid island collectibles not having any expectation.. I was significantly impressed with their game options and customer service. Mark was very welcoming the moment i walked in. Seems to be genuine individuals working there and they have a LARGE selection of games, Knick nacks and cards..

  3 months ago

• Akarui Kaze ★★★★★

  This place is wonderful! Amazing Prices! Family Friendly! Pokemon, Comics, and Magic Oh My! ❤️

  3 months ago

• Hailey Abreu ★★★★★

  They were incredibly nice and honestly cool people. When we had some hesitation with the console they didn’t immediately blame it on me which is a problem I’ve had in the past. Also when I bought the console they didn’t give off that vibe that I should just go I actually spoke to them about my goal with Nintendo and Pokemon stuff. They were overall really nice and I loved this store and 10/10 recommend it! (Side Note The gameboy I got was one of the cheapest I’ve ever seen and if fully functional and same with the pokemon game)

  3 months ago

• Ricky James ★★★★★

  Awesome service

  3 months ago

• alex diamond ★★★★★

  Amazing store and vibe 10/10

  2 weeks ago

• Darryl Menchan Jr ★★★★★

  Great business with the Pokemon card merchants here!!! Will continue business. Must recommend!!!

  3 weeks ago

• Robert Jahn ★★★★★

  Greg and the rest of the vendors were great. Helped me with get the most for my collection.

  3 weeks ago

• Scott Mergl ★★★★★

  Place is awesome. They have a ton of rare or unique pieces and the people are even better.

  3 weeks ago