New York Card Marketplace

Highlights

• ✨Vibe

  "Finally got a chance to go here today. The owner was very professional and friendly. His prices were good too. My daughter loved it because she pulled an IR from perfect order and got a keychain too. Left with ascended heroes booster boxes and Paladean set as well. We are definitely coming back and it’s worth the trip."

  — Sean Lynch

• 📚Selection

  "Great card shop that recently just opened up. Came in for one pack and left questioning my life choices. The Pokemon inventory here is actually insane they’ve got EVERYTHING. Great prices, great people, and way too many things I now need. Highly recommend."

  — c v

• 🧠Staff

  "Great card shop that recently just opened up. Came in for one pack and left questioning my life choices. The Pokemon inventory here is actually insane they’ve got EVERYTHING. Great prices, great people, and way too many things I now need. Highly recommend."

  — c v

• 💵Prices

  "Great card shop that recently just opened up. Came in for one pack and left questioning my life choices. The Pokemon inventory here is actually insane they’ve got EVERYTHING. Great prices, great people, and way too many things I now need. Highly recommend."

  — c v

About this shop

New York Card Marketplace is a brick-and-mortar trading card shop in Brookhaven, New York. The shop carries Pokémon. Customer reviews give New York Card Marketplace a 5.0-star average across 4 ratings. Reviewers specifically mention vintage, owner-run. Hours, phone, directions, and recent reviews are below — call ahead to confirm stock for the cards or sealed product you're looking for.

Card shop in Brookhaven, NY · part of our directory of trading card stores across New York.

Map

Hours

• Sean Lynch ★★★★★

  Finally got a chance to go here today. The owner was very professional and friendly. His prices were good too. My daughter loved it because she pulled an IR from perfect order and got a keychain too. Left with ascended heroes booster boxes and Paladean set as well. We are definitely coming back and it’s worth the trip.

  a month ago

• Jack DeGennaro ★★★★★

  Absolutely amazing place to stumble upon they are open late on Sundays so im very happy to spend here

  a month ago

• Junior Herrera (Jrbuilt) ★★★★★

  Had to check out this recently opened card shop, can definitely say it will be an experience I’ll remember. They had every sort of Pokémon options, every flavor, from vintage to mid era to modern. Met the owner and gave me a very fair price for everything I decided to purchase, love it!

  a month ago

• c v ★★★★★

  Great card shop that recently just opened up. Came in for one pack and left questioning my life choices. The Pokemon inventory here is actually insane they’ve got EVERYTHING. Great prices, great people, and way too many things I now need. Highly recommend.

  a month ago