Overtime Sports

Highlights

• ✨Vibe

  "Very friendly owner and had so e great chiefs memorabilia!!"

  — Ronald Widman

• 📚Selection

  "Great prices and selection. Jerseys are crazy cool."

  — Harry Espiritu

• 🧠Staff

  "Very good. Employees were nice and very helpful."

  — Terri-emmy bird songs Watkins

• 💵Prices

  "I like this place! Great prices on stuff"

  — Mary Whipple

Map

Hours

• Courtney N ★★★★★

  Love this place! Everyone is really friendly and greet you by name when you become a regular. Great group of people. I enjoy their selection of both Pokémon Cards and Sports Memorabilia. They also carry jerseys and have a great selection.

  4 months ago

• Sam DJ ★★★★★

  I’ve been to card shops all across the country, and “Overtime” has the best vintage selection I’ve ever come across. The customer service is truly outstanding, and their prices are always fair. Thank you for creating such an awesome shop—I’ll be sure to stop by every time I’m back in the area!

  8 months ago

• joshua kessell ★★★★★

  WHAT A GREAT SHOP... I walked in on a Saturday afternoon and I had never been to this shop. I was greeted immediately by the owner and he made me feel like family. We chatted for about 30 minutes looking at all the different cards he had in Whitch I had no clue they sold cards at all. What a great experience by a small local business I will continue to shop here and keep my money locally with small business as much as I can!! Thanks for being such great people

  10 months ago

• Jeslynn Clark ★

  I called them 3 times trying to ask if they would take a signed hockey stick I have, no answer at all how am I supposed to trust them for good customer service if they can’t even answer their phone?

  6 months ago

• keith roberts ★★★★★

  While traveling I like to stop and check out local card shops. Finding Overtime Sports was absolutely an awesome find in my opinion. The shop was set up greatly and in my opinion felt like a shop back in the 80-90's. Had a great selection and the staff was amazing. I highly recommend take a look if your in the area. I know I'll be back next trip for sure.

  a year ago

• Robert Beltran ★★★★★

  Nice friendly local card shop. Bought a few D.Booker cards at the show about a month ago. Returned for Father's Day and purchased some NBA Boxes. Had some great pulls! The gentleman also gave me a handful of fathers day cards and a panini Nascar toy for my son. Definitely will be back.

  4 years ago

• Tom Rief ★★★★★

  Now that's a sports card shop. 5 stars. A+ selection. A+ staff and A+ owner. Spent a couple hours going through a few boxes. Very nice place for a true collectors. Thanks and I hope to visit again. Tomsbaseballcards from Washington ⚾

  a year ago

• Katherine Andrews ★★★★★

  Always love coming here. Super friendly staff and great selection of cards!

  8 months ago