Price's Collectibles

Highlights

• ✨Vibe

  "Always friendly and helpful. Highly Recommended"

  — Mark Stetzl

• 📚Selection

  "Best selection of Sport Cards and Collectibles!!"

  — Cooper Fellows

• 🧠Staff

  "The staff is fabulous and very knowledgeable"

  — Sa Gt

• 💵Prices

  "Mount Rushmore!!!! The Price is Right$$$"

  — Eugene Miner

Map

Hours

• Peter Larsen ★★★★★

  My go to for all sports, Pokémon, and sport collectibles. I also use him for my psa and sgc submissions. Great guy that is very knowledgeable and always willing to talk and share stories. He has some fun stories, stop in and hear them!!! Plus you never know who you’re going to run into in the shop!!! I was lucky enough to meet and get a picture with hall of Famer Leroy Butler who came in and talked to me and the owner Jeff! He came in to pick up stuff from the owner to give out to the kids!! Both great guys!!!

  9 months ago

• Tony Wiedenheft ★★★★★

  Just wanted to give a huge shout out to Price’s Collectible! Jeff runs one of the most welcoming, family-friendly card shops around. Always fair with prices, and I really appreciate how honest he is when it comes to grading advice. He actually tells you if a card is worth grading based on your expectations. Every time I stop in, it’s a great experience. If you are into cards, definitely check this place out. 👍

  4 months ago

• Alexander Renish ★★★★★

  The store atmosphere is amazing, owner is super respectful and kind - seems to always be having a more personable conversation with anyone that comes in or a regular. Card and collectibles variety is enough to always discover something new with each visit. Stars wars, sports cards, Pokémon, keepsakes. Can’t give a high enough review for this business

  4 months ago

• Steven Karides ★★★★★

  ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Outstanding service and an incredible selection of hard-to-find collectibles. Price Collectables in Greendale is a true gem — knowledgeable, trustworthy, and professional every step of the way. They’ve built a proven track record over the years, and it shows in both their inventory and customer care. If you’re a serious collector or just looking for something special, this is the place to go. Highly recommended!

  5 months ago

• Matthew Leon ★★★★★

  Very nostalgic being able come back to Wisconsin and seeing this place that I remember as a kid being in southridge mall. They treated my kids like family and I had a great time looking at a legitimate card store for the first time in a number of years. Love the ambience, the atmosphere, the people, and the experience. Will ensure that we stop by every time we’re back in Wisconsin!

  6 months ago

• nick nes ★★★★★

  Best card shop in Wisconsin hands down! Super helpful with card submissions as well.

  5 months ago

• C2C Card Store Reviews ★★★★★

  🐋🐦🐳 Blue Ribbon🐋🐦🐳 **Best Sports Card Store in Wisconsin State Award** Jeff is probably the most knowledgeable store owner I've come across in my travels. He's a bona fide card expert, if I need advice or answers, he's the guy I go to. This is the only card store I can recommend to do business with in the Milwaukee or Wisconsin area.

  Edited 3 months ago

• Aaron Grabowski ★★★★★

  Awesome place, with an awesome owner! Had an old kirby auto that he helped me send in to get graded. Was nervous but was in great hands with Price's Collectibles. Only place I would go!

  5 months ago