The Collector Cubby

Highlights

• ✨Vibe

  "Great prices and friendly staff! Cheapest in NYC that I found"

  — Joshua Ang

• 📚Selection

  "Cheaper prices than majority of card shops. They aren't buying singles yet as they just opened. The customer service was top notched. Owner is a doll <3"

  — El Montenegro

• 🧠Staff

  "Great prices and friendly staff! Cheapest in NYC that I found"

  — Joshua Ang

• 💵Prices

  "Great prices and friendly staff! Cheapest in NYC that I found"

  — Joshua Ang

About this shop

The Collector Cubby is a brick-and-mortar trading card shop in Brooklyn, New York. The shop carries Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering. Customer reviews give The Collector Cubby a 5.0-star average across 28 ratings. Reviewers specifically mention singles, expert staff, owner-run, snacks. Hours, phone, directions, and recent reviews are below — call ahead to confirm stock for the cards or sealed product you're looking for.

Card shop in Brooklyn, NY · part of our directory of trading card stores across New York.

Map

Hours

• Yesenia Figuereo ★★★★★

  The Collector Cubby is hands down one of the best trading card shops I’ve been to. From the moment you walk in, it feels like a real community, welcoming, friendly, and genuinely excited to help collectors at every level. The location is super convenient, the atmosphere is always on point, and everything is set up in a way that makes you want to hang out, browse, and talk cards. What really sets this place apart is how flexible and accommodating they are with scheduling and events, it makes it easy to stop by even when you’re busy. And the pulls? Let’s just say The Collector Cubby brings the l

  5 months ago

• Stephanie Montenegro ★★★★★

  This is a hidden gem for pokémon and magic the gathering. The community here really made me feel welcome when I was first getting into each game, and I couldn't be more appreciative that this is where I learned to play. I keep coming back every week for the reasonable prices and friendly environment. The bakery is also a plus!

  5 months ago

• N T ★★★★★

  Great card shop for players and collectors. Better prices and service than the Manhattan spots. Owner is a good guy. Highly recommend even for out of town visitors!!

  6 months ago

• Steven Baquerizo ★★★★★

  What I love most is the sense of community. They regularly host events and tournaments (primarily Pokemon and MTG, but they recently started hosting Star Wars Unlimited), making it a fantastic place to meet fellow collectors and player alike. It feels more like a gathering of friends than just a shopping trip.

  a year ago

• Ant C ★★★★★

  Jonathan is the best, found out this place in march and I stop by regularly, fairest price you’re going to find anywhere. Also check out the bakery, best desserts and coffee ever!

  9 months ago

• R F ★★★★★

  Jonathan was so nice , he also had an incredible selection of sealed pokemon! Lots of celebrations, even break point sealed booster packs. Definitely worth dropping by in person, also very well priced product. Overall great experience and we will definitely be back soon !

  a year ago

• Jc Entertainment ★★★★★

  Amazing local card shop, I’m a Pokemon collector and to see the variety of packs and cards on display was dope to see, the plus is you can order a coffee and pastry and enjoy your day opening a few packs. Great place to visit, I will be returning soon thanks Cubby!

  a year ago

• Ryan Battle ★★★★★

  Recently got into collecting Pokemon and The Collector Cubby is a stellar spot for those looking to get into the hobby or find some good single cards!

  8 months ago