The Collector's Cave

Highlights

• ✨Vibe

  "Very good staff. Very friendly and welcoming."

  — James Crescitelli

• 📚Selection

  "Great place, very welcoming & friendly staff. Great selection of comics, cards & toys."

  — Vito Di Maio

• 🧠Staff

  "Great cards! Fair prices & very helpful!"

  — Odd Asvp

• 💵Prices

  "Great cards! Fair prices & very helpful!"

  — Odd Asvp

Map

Hours

• Joseph Iacono ★★★★★

  Finally, an amazing place in a great location in Great kills. The collectors cave has a vast amount of cards and memorabilia that sure to bring out the kid in you. The staff is extremely friendly and very knowledgeable and my son spends many days here searching for the perfect card. Great for any hobbies I would highly recommend the collectors cave if you’re in the area.

  a year ago

• Steven Shinkar ★★★★★

  The shop is absolutely incredible. It has something for everyone of all ages and all interests from vintage sports cards and Pokémon to all the new and exclusive products that nobody can get their hands on. The professionalism displayed during my visit was unmatched. These are a bunch of guys who love what they do, and ensure that every person who walks through the door feels like family and part of the Collector’s Cave culture. Highly highly highly recommended for all!

  7 months ago

• DeepCollection ★

  If you’re into Pokémon or TCG, this shop will probably be fine. If you’re a sports card collector, the experience may be very different. I originally came because I was told they could give general PSA grading opinions for a $5 fee per card, which they did during a prior visit for about 8 cards. When I returned with newly released 2026 Topps Series 1 cards, I was suddenly told they no longer provide estimates since they got PSA license — which was surprising considering I had just received estimates literally a week ago with different staff. When I mentioned this, the staff made an excuse. T

  3 months ago

• Robert SM ★★★★★

  Excellent shop with incredibly friendly and helpful staff. Dylan in particular really looks out for regulars and has formed a community of players there that all look forward to visiting the shop. If you haven’t yet, definitely give this shop a try. They offer Magic, One Piece and Pokemon cards and host tournaments for them as well. Thanks so much Dylan!!

  6 months ago

• Vincent Como ★★★★★

  Great selection of cards from sports to Pokemon to one piece. Staff is always super friendly, helpful and kind! Dylan is super cool too!

  6 months ago

• anthony morro ★★★★★

  Had some cards to grade, at the shop. Sales man behind the counter said, save your money because they were not worth it. I left and went to a different place(will not expose). Sure enough, collector s cave was 100 spot on. Could of save 200.00 dollars

  3 months ago

• f brank ★

  tried to order a booster box of a new TCG a week or so after it's official launch (a launch date I knew for a fact because of people I knew and official communication from the company running it) and the shop said they could order me a box. I paid them for a box and was told to wait a week and I would get a call when they come in. a week passes, nothing. so I gave them a call and was told the distributor split the shipment up in a weird way and it would be coming in a few days. no big deal, I can wait. another week passes with no communication from the shop so I called again. I forget what th

  7 months ago

• pariah ★★★★★

  First time in the shop and I needed some cards for my deck, Dylan was really nice and helped me sort through the bulk to find what I needed. Would recommend for the friendly atmosphere!

  6 months ago