The Nerd Store

Highlights

• ✨Vibe

  "Amazing selection. This store is dangerous to my wallet every time I walk in. I want to buy everything! The staff is friendly and knowledgeable. Great for weekly MTG games."

  — Samantha Haviland

• 📚Selection

  "Amazing selection. This store is dangerous to my wallet every time I walk in. I want to buy everything! The staff is friendly and knowledgeable. Great for weekly MTG games."

  — Samantha Haviland

• 🧠Staff

  "Amazing selection. This store is dangerous to my wallet every time I walk in. I want to buy everything! The staff is friendly and knowledgeable. Great for weekly MTG games."

  — Samantha Haviland

About this shop

The Nerd Store is a brick-and-mortar trading card shop in Greeley, Colorado. The shop carries Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering. Customer reviews give The Nerd Store a 4.6-star average across 774 ratings. Reviewers specifically mention expert staff, open late. Hours, phone, directions, and recent reviews are below — call ahead to confirm stock for the cards or sealed product you're looking for.

Card shop in Greeley, CO · part of our directory of trading card stores across Colorado.

Map

Hours

• Christie M ★★★★★

  Great store! Amazing, knowledgeable staff, lots of unique options. Trading cards, fun fidget things, events, and more! Check it out! You will not be disappointed. There is something for EVERYONE here!

  3 months ago

• Brandon Sparks ★★★★★

  The name says it all. Do you like nerdy things? Do you enjoy painting your fingertips with multiple colors from an airbrush? Is there a board game you've been itching to try? Can't find that one commander to complete your deck or that one pokemon to finally catch them all? Well they probably have it here. I live in Loveland and try to find excuses to drive 35 minutes to swing by here.

  10 months ago

• Crissy J ★★★★★

  There is something for everyone here! The token machines are my favorite a bit pricey but well worth it. Kinda busy in the evening but no wait to check out. The store is a bit small and has tons of stuff inside if you have a big purse I wouldn't recommend taking it inside.

  a year ago

• Samantha Haviland ★★★★★

  Amazing selection. This store is dangerous to my wallet every time I walk in. I want to buy everything! The staff is friendly and knowledgeable. Great for weekly MTG games.

  6 months ago

• Brandon Hurst ★★★★★

  Super cool place! I love it! Old toys I haven't seen since I was a kid in the 90's. Brings me back.

  3 months ago

• Michael Harrison ★★★★★

  Thank you for the help! I was doing an angel tree for a child who liked a certain anime/manga and I personally had no idea what I was looking for. The employees offered help and pointed me in the right direction, giving me options in all price ranges. I really appreciate the help in getting this kid exactly what they wanted :)

  6 months ago

• Ty Bowman ★★★★★

  My all time favorite store and vibe in general love the selection and personality the working staff is amazing and Frendly and I'm not the most approachable person in public alone after prison but I always feel welcomed.

  4 months ago

• MK ★

  I do not recommend this store at all. No variety of items. Also to mention how unsanitary this store is. It smells so bad in here!! Workers are beyond rude as well

  3 months ago