America's Pastime

Highlights

• ✨Vibe

  "Purchased a few baseball cards at the store, great service and friendly staff."

  — Jason Blevins

• 📚Selection

  "Great selection and good prices on boxes and supplies."

  — Noah

• 🧠Staff

  "COOL SMALL BUISNESS OWNER IS A VERY NICE GUY"

  — Matthew Chiz

• 🎟️Events

  "Does anyone know if he buys cards i am comming up fron floruda for a ufc card event and i am looking to off load some autos and psa slabs for a steal doe anyone know if he buys cards?? Jb@ SA"

  — Justin Betsch

• 💵Prices

  "Great selection and good prices on boxes and supplies."

  — Noah

Map

Hours

• Ariana Sclafani ★★★★★

  America’s past time is a Burton County gem. Rich really knows his stuff which is refreshing in a world with most retail interactions I feel like I know more than the worker does. He’s attentive without hovering yet gives an honest advice and generally cares about getting you the right item not just the most expensive one. Whether you’re shopping for sports cards autographs or a sports gift he makes the process smooth and enjoyable. He’s got a great selection great service and a real gentleman. If you want quality without nonsense come to America’s Pastime. 💙

  5 months ago

• andersen dekoyer ★

  Horrible service i walked in twice the guy paid no attention to me then when i finally got his attention he took my card to check the price and instead of telling me the price he came back extremely frustrated and said he couldn’t do it. Also prices are extremely high compared to other shops.

  4 months ago

• Harrison Potash ★

  Purchased 3 high-end vintage “sealed” packs from the owner of the shop. All 3 packs were “altered” as per PSA. Owner refused to resolve the issue.

  7 months ago

• 718 Breaks ★

  If you’re looking to walk into a shop and feel like you’re completely inconveniencing the owner this is the place for you. Came in here earlier as I was driving past this town & needed some inventory. Told the shop owner what I needed and he rudely asked me to clarify multiple times before I finally clarified well enough for him to tell me that they don’t have what I need & only have cards 30+ years older. I then looked in his showcases & saw he had some things I could have used but after being talked to like that decided it wasn’t worth my time to deal with this individual so I said thanks

  a year ago

• layla sanchez ★★★★★

  Bought pokémon cards for my brother. Rich was extremely helpful thankyou again!!

  4 months ago

• Carlitosturbo2 ★★★★★

  Rich is an awesome guy. Whatever cards you need he'll go out of his way to make sure you get it. I've been looking for a complete 93' SP for a long time and he found it within a day. And if you're running low on funds you can make a layaway account with him. Just great service. Now I finally have my Jeter rookie card.

  Edited 6 years ago

• Tony Arabian ★★★★★

  Rich is the best was patient helpful and has great prices , highly recommend him

  4 months ago

• Carol Frye ★★★★★

  I have years of buying from America Pastimes cards. Owner Richard is really a good guy, gives honest fair prices and is genuinely friendly and kind. Cards from America Pastimes NJ are always in great condition every sale every time! Check out America Pastimes card selections at the shop or at the next card show.

  a year ago