The Baseball Card Store Inc

Highlights

• ✨Vibe

  "Great selection of cards and very friendly"

  — Mike Reid

• 📚Selection

  "Great selection of cards and very friendly"

  — Mike Reid

• 🧠Staff

  "Super helpful and friendly. Thank you so much!"

  — Hannah Canario

• 💵Prices

  "Great staff, prices are great, highly recommended!"

  — Elad Shushan

Map

Hours

• Ethan Goya ★

  I go around to different card shops and give honest reviews based on presentation, ownership and prices. I gotta say the remodel is great but prices are way above market. Looking at other stores in the area they are priced more reasonable than this place. Next ownership the guy working has no energy and makes it very uncomfortable for others trying to shop when he is just staring at you the whole time. Have to say the other owners definitely took more time and care. Prices are above market and I do have to say you can find other hobby stores with more inventory and better prices in Bergen coun

  3 months ago

• Randi Rubin-Zellea ★

  I think you all can see based on the owners responses to negative feedback that he is not looking to improve his customer service. He does not take the feedback as a way to improve his business. He makes excuses. Go elsewhere. WOW in Randolph is the best as well as Hidden Gems in Hackettstown. Btw Mr. Owner- my husband always tells my son to not expect to spend any money and then the always does. We prefer our son buy something he loves rather than buy just because he knows he has money to spend.

  3 months ago

• Daniel Stepien ★★★★★

  Really nice hobby store, with Pokémon and all types of sports cards. Great selection of holders and protective cases. Picked up some 49ers singles to add to my collection and they were the first store to carry 2025 NFL Panini Prizm, so was super excited to pick up a blaster box. Looking forward to stopping in again.

  5 months ago

• Randy Zellea ★★

  This is a little late but still relevant…we used to live in Bergen county and had some time to spare and my son loves sports cards …and didn’t even realize the shop had new owners… I always liked coming here as the owners were always nice to my stepson’s especially since they have special needs ..my son likes to ask a lot of questions ..just his nature.. as I was talking with another shopper about sports ..I over heard my son ask questions and the man behind the counter who I do not think was the actual owner sort of brush of my son when it came to pricing…gave him an attitude when wanting to

  4 months ago

• Christopher ★

  Do yourself a favor and go to Monmouth Sports cards - also in Midland Park. The people that work there are way nicer. My teenage son asked the owner of this place a simple, and fair question regarding a box of cards that said on the outside of that the box contained a mystery card, to which my 13 year old son asked a fair and thoughtful question, "what sort of mystery cards are usually included in those boxes to which the owner responded, I don't know, I didn't put the box of cards together." Whereas the owner could have just been nicer about it and said, I don't know and then left it at that.

  7 months ago

• Julia Miller ★★★★★

  Amazing selection and customer service. I walked in just before closing on a Friday evening and was met with extremely helpful associates who helped me pick out hockey cards for every player on my son’s mites team for an upcoming tournament swag bag. They had tons of hockey cards to choose from but we went with vintage 90s packs and can’t beat the price. Super helpful and friendly. Highly recommend!

  4 years ago

• Ryan Rozman ★

  Rude. Wanted to see prices on sealed products. Yelled at to not approach. Was only person in store. Weird. Never coming back

  5 months ago

• A ★

  I don’t ever leave reviews… but I was so thrown off by the guys immediate standoffish character that I just had to warn people about this place. I ask the guy how much a card was going for, (to make conversation cuz it was awkward inside there), and said “Make me an offer” .. meanwhile someone else comes in and asks for the price on a different card and immediately tells them the price on it. I wouldn’t do business with this guy in terms of trading. Need something and his store has it? Buy what you need and walk out. Terrible. 0/5 stars.

  10 months ago