Bullseye Collectibles

Highlights

• ✨Vibe

  "Great lcs with friendly owner and wonderful vibes"

  — Aidan Beznicki

• 📚Selection

  "Great store. Nice selection and excellent prices!"

  — Luke Mackay

• 🧠Staff

  "Great lcs with friendly owner and wonderful vibes"

  — Aidan Beznicki

• 💵Prices

  "Amazing store, amazing prices, Paul is the best!"

  — Benjamin Trink

About this shop

Bullseye Collectibles is a brick-and-mortar trading card shop in Merrick, New York. The shop carries Pokémon, Sports Cards. Customer reviews give Bullseye Collectibles a 4.8-star average across 40 ratings. Reviewers specifically mention expert staff, owner-run, casual. Hours, phone, directions, and recent reviews are below — call ahead to confirm stock for the cards or sealed product you're looking for.

Card shop in Merrick, NY · part of our directory of trading card stores across New York.

Map

Hours

• Shane Rossi ★★★★★

  Good guy shop is small but he has some good product. Nostalgic experience and he always had cards in a nationwide shortage

  3 years ago

• Joe Garraffo ★★★★★

  Had the urge to rip some packs. So happy I stopped in. Paul is a great guy. Very knowledgeable!

  a year ago

• Aidan Beznicki ★★★★★

  Great lcs with friendly owner and wonderful vibes

  9 months ago

• Daniel Coleman ★★★★★

  Paul is the man!!! Full of knowledge on all sports, and every item he has in the store. Have been a frequent customer for a few months now, and refuse to go anywhere else for memorabilia. Very wide selection of sports cards. Will be returning ASAP!

  3 years ago

• Saddy Snow ★★★★★

  Cute little place

  a year ago

• William Pagan ★★★

  Gave it 3 stars as not to kill what is probably a nice man with a small business.. Google says they are open on Monday.. they are not . Sign in window is faded so not something new I am guessing... take a few a update your Google listing! Maybe I will try again...

  7 years ago

• Neal Roth ★★★★

  Paul is great. He has a wide selection and is friendly, personable, and knowledgeable. One of my all time favorite hobby shops.

  7 years ago

• Alex Sodokov ★★★★★

  Best card shop and owner on the island. Paul is personable, reliable and honest. There is nowhere else I would go after years in the hobby.

  3 years ago