Card Shops Finder

Heart Of The Game

85 S Rossler Ave, Buffalo, NY 14206

★★★★★ 4.5 · 579 reviews
PokémonMagic: The GatheringYu-Gi-Oh! 🪑Play space 🏛️Vintage

Highlights

  • Vibe

    "Great people. Very welcoming environment"

    — Anthony Zummo

  • 📚Selection

    "Swagged out, cool vintage games, massive selection"

    — Nathan Drake Czarniak

  • 🧠Staff

    "Friendly and helpful staff. Decent prices"

    — Haley Smith

  • 🎟️Events

    "My weekly FNM and table top store. Staff is very knowledgable and always there to help if possible."

    — Jonathan Lynch

  • 💵Prices

    "Friendly and helpful staff. Decent prices"

    — Haley Smith

Map

Hours

Monday 2–10 PM
Tuesday 2–10 PM
Wednesday 2–10 PM
Thursday• today 2–10 PM
Friday 10 AM–12 AM
Saturday 10 AM–12 AM
Sunday 10 AM–10 PM

Recent reviews

8 of 579
  • Michael the Mountainous ★★★★★

    OMG! This store literally has it all, I went in on one of their MtG nights and it was the most ridiculous amount of fun Ive had in quite sometime! The staff are incredibly knowledgeable, very kind and fair when selling older cards or just in general, and they have just about any game you can think of! I had an absolute blast playing, I didn't win but that's not the point, once you get there you're just happy to be a part of the fun and the other patrons are super friendly and are just happy to be there amongst others that enjoy games as much as you or I do! Please, do yourself a huge favor and

    5 months ago

  • Dan Ruckus ★★★★★

    I come here often for Thursday and Sunday night commander. Great group to play with, pre releases are a blast. Wide selection of magic, pokemon and video games. Would highly recommend for a local store for new and returning gamers

    6 months ago

  • Scott Pugh ★★★★★

    My son wanted to check this place out and ask questions about Warhammer. HOLY CRAP, the place is HUUUUGGGE! Lots of board games, old school video games, and role playing games. AND, more importantly, the staff was both knowledgeable and helpful answering his questions. We will be back once he has some pennies saved.

    3 months ago

  • Low Test

    I wish I could give 0 or negative stars on this. First, yes… they have retro games and systems. Yes, they sell magic and other cards. Prices aren’t awful but not great. That’s about where it ends They aren’t friendly. They don’t smile. They don’t help. They don’t welcome. They stand behind the counter on their phone and don’t say a single word when you’re the ONLY person there. I have given this place chance after chance and have tried to engage the workers without them talking first, still fails. I hope this store closes so their inventory will go to someone that gives a care, even in the

    6 months ago

  • Jonathan Krollman ★★★★

    The store is good and has a decent amount of staple stock for higher tier play. For anyone who is a collector of a number of games you will find the employees useful in either knowledge or deck construction assistance.

    6 months ago

  • Melissa Karsky ★★★★★

    They have a wide variety of cards for magic, Pokémon and others. Great staff and fun events weekly and daily! Personally i love that they have a girls night on Tuesday for magic!

    6 months ago

  • C. Hasenauer ★★★★★

    Cool shop, having later hours on Friday and Saturday is really particularly cool. I'm from Rochester so I don't get out this way very often, and I'm a little spoiled with the card shop in my town. However my trip here was really enjoyable, I was able to look through cards physically which is a really cool thing. Good prices on cards and games. Will return.

    9 months ago

  • logan ★★★★★

    These guys were so kind. I got a CRT TV from them for a PS2. They have one left as of 09-25-25. They even let me use their equipment to get it to my truck. They have a great stock in all your hobby needs. Will be coming back for some 40k stuff and games. Thanks guys

    8 months ago

More shops near Buffalo

Harlequin Hobby

2070 Clinton St, Cheektowaga, NY 14206

★★★★★
4.9 · 128
Magic: The GatheringSports Cards 🪑Play space

Bases Loaded Sports Collectibles

2350 Union Rd, West Seneca, NY 14224

★★★★★
4.5 · 104
PokémonSports Cards 🛡️Grading

Favorety LLC

23 Flohr Ave 23 23, West Seneca, NY 14224

★★★★★
5.0 · 2
Sports Cards 🌙Open late

Empire Comics

1069 Abbott Rd, Buffalo, NY 14220

★★★★★
4.8 · 149
🛡️Grading 🧠Expert staff 🏠Owner-run

Top Cut Cards

43 Kelly Dr, Cheektowaga, NY 14227

★★★★★
4.7 · 71
PokémonMagic: The GatheringYu-Gi-Oh!

Great Escape Adventures - Walden Galleria

1 Walden Galleria J203, Buffalo, NY 14225

★★★★
4.3 · 79
PokémonMagic: The Gathering 🃏FNM