NewCastle Comics & Games

Highlights

• ✨Vibe

  "First time here. Selection is great. Owner is very friendly. Will return!"

  — Mojito

• 📚Selection

  "First time here. Selection is great. Owner is very friendly. Will return!"

  — Mojito

• 🧠Staff

  "First time here. Selection is great. Owner is very friendly. Will return!"

  — Mojito

Map

Hours

• Socks Anonymous ★★★★★

  Love their shop! They've got a good variety of different comic books and board games. I like checking out their Warhammer books too and they have some hardcovers! Always pleased with their customer service as well. They're always able to answer my questions and guide me to things I might be interested in 😁👍

  5 months ago

• JD Feuerstein ★★★★★

  Edit as of 11/16/2025 Yup, still awesome. --------------------- The staff are friendly, knowledgeable, and make you feel welcome. What's even better is they are priced more competitively than Amazon AND IT'S LOCAL! They have a wide array of comics across all the minor and major publishers, a fairly large selection of tabletop game figurines and their associated supporting materials, and a few trading card game packs like Pokémon & Magic The Gathering. I've already been back 3 times now and will certainly be returning again to get my comic book fix!

  Edited 6 months ago

• Robert J ★★★★

  Large diverse collection of board games, including some deluxe or unique editions. The high inventory and variety in a smaller store can make it difficult to find what you’re looking for. Will return!

  6 months ago

• Mikhaela Press (Kyki) ★★★★★

  Perry decent selection of new and older comic books. A lot of game accessories. The staff has always been nice to interact with.

  4 months ago

• Karston McPheters ★★★★★

  I love this place. They always have a great selection and get all the newest comics. They have a huge selection of boardgames and drinks and snacks and stuff.

  5 months ago

• Dustin Smith ★★★★★

  Was visiting from AZ and checking stores while on vacay. Great little shop. Very clean and open design. Staff very helpful and informative and willing to engage in conversation unlike most of the stores I found north of them (I only checked out stores in Longmont/Loveland/Greeley/Ft. Collins). The atmosphere was such a warmer feeling and didn't have that stuck in the 90s live in my parents basement feel of a comic store (best way I can think of) than a few of the other stores I visited in Loveland and Greeley. Loved the drawer system utilized for the back issues which also aides in the clean l

  4 years ago

• Gabe Shakour ★★★★★

  Probably one of the best game and comic shops that I’ve ever visited. Lots of inventory with a nice atmosphere and cool touches like a drink cooler selling Japanese sodas and bubble tea.

  4 years ago

• Mojito ★★★★★

  First time here. Selection is great. Owner is very friendly. Will return!

  3 months ago