PapaJay Cards

Highlights

• ✨Vibe

  "These guys have the best prices in town, work with their customers, very chill and professional. Serg, Elijah, Joe and Fonz and all great! I always enjoy coming to this shop."

  — Justin Brandt

• 📚Selection

  "Store was stocked up. Specially Pokemon. Picked up pretty good cards. Staff was great and informative. I recommend."

  — mike trafalgar

• 🧠Staff

  "Great place to shop....helpful, knowledgeable staff. Fun Friday night events!! Thank you so much."

  — Barb G

• 💵Prices

  "Really fair prices, exceptional selection of English pokemon singles, and has bulk boxes for $1-10 with a lot of neat stuff."

  — scottmelons

Map

Hours

• Justin Brandt ★★★★★

  These guys have the best prices in town, work with their customers, very chill and professional. Serg, Elijah, Joe and Fonz and all great! I always enjoy coming to this shop.

  4 months ago

• Kitty DatKat ★★★★★

  Amazing service and shockingly reasonable market/storefront prices. Sent my boyfriend in to get his MTG commander deck and a few booster packs for me, and he reported his experience. Thank you Papajay cards! You will be seeing us around!

  5 months ago

• holychit88 88hvac ★★★★★

  WARNING . PAPA Js is going to be a multiple go to if you got young kids... Came up to visit and my boy wanted to check out this highly rated shop. And I understand why. Well stocked, well lit, and friendly helpful staff. We parked ourselves on a table and chairs and went through boxes of packaged cards that were cased. Asked questions, spoke about card value, made the kids recognize alot of things of value. went through hundreds of cards , and was really fun to see the kids into it. So good the first time, on our way home my son talked my daughter into going. Cool thing is that staff too

  2 years ago

• Barb G ★★★★★

  Great place to shop....helpful, knowledgeable staff. Fun Friday night events!! Thank you so much.

  3 months ago

• scottmelons ★★★★★

  Really fair prices, exceptional selection of English pokemon singles, and has bulk boxes for $1-10 with a lot of neat stuff.

  6 months ago

• mike trafalgar ★★★★★

  Store was stocked up. Specially Pokemon. Picked up pretty good cards. Staff was great and informative. I recommend.

  6 months ago

• Michael Britton ★★★★★

  These guys are awesome! They have something for everyone when it comes to cards. I collect hard to find (in store) F1 cards. They had a case worth of hard to find 23 Topps Chrome F1. They were almost $100 cheaper per hobby box than Ebay. My wife was lucky to pull a Hamilton auto as well as a Leclerc auto/50 and a bunch other numbered cards. Highly recommend Papajay Cards. They go above and beyond for their customers. Even hooked me up with some top loaders and penny sleeves. Will definitely be coming back!

  9 months ago

• Ryan ★★★★★

  (Pokémon specific review) Amazing little card shop that always has great options and great selection of newer and older cards and sets as well as singles, everyone is always very friendly and everything very reasonably priced. Besides Pokémon, they seem to have a good selection of sports cards as well for those collectors.

  10 months ago