Pony Express Sports & More

Highlights

• ✨Vibe

  "The guys that own this are extremely friendly and knowledgeable. Pricing is amazing"

  — David Allison

• 📚Selection

  "Very personal, and professional with a huge variety of products for every sports fan, oh yeah great prices too! Thanks agan!"

  — Mike Green

• 🧠Staff

  "The guys that own this are extremely friendly and knowledgeable. Pricing is amazing"

  — David Allison

• 💵Prices

  "Very personal, and professional with a huge variety of products for every sports fan, oh yeah great prices too! Thanks agan!"

  — Mike Green

About this shop

Pony Express Sports & More is a brick-and-mortar trading card shop in Independence, Missouri. The shop carries Sports Cards. Customer reviews give Pony Express Sports & More a 4.5-star average across 40 ratings. Reviewers specifically mention expert staff, owner-run. Hours, phone, directions, and recent reviews are below — call ahead to confirm stock for the cards or sealed product you're looking for.

Card shop in Independence, MO · part of our directory of trading card stores across Missouri.

Map

Hours

• Jacob Larue ★

  Very terrible experience. Id be very skeptical of how they do business.

  5 months ago

• jason campbell ★★★★★

  Great place for all sport fans!!

  3 months ago

• Tara Blunt ★★★★★

  Me and my husband absolutely love this! We live about an hour away but every time we make the trip we go in. The man who runs the store, maybe even owns the store is absolutely amazing. My husband is always excited to talk to him about sports cards and get his advice or what he thinks. I wish you had more raiders cards LOL but my husband is pretty content with all of the Chiefs cards 😁 thank you for being so amazing and such a wonderful store. We will be back soon.

  2 years ago

• Dani G ★★★★★

  So much awesome stuff! Fair prices! Awesome people who work here too! Literally everything you could imagine. If they don’t have it, they can order it for you!

  8 years ago

• John mcreable benson (Lewby2728) ★★★★

  they do not have any hockey souvenirs but besides that it is a nice store and a nice guy owns it

  4 years ago

• John Wesley Huss ★★★★★

  Carleo and Paul are both very friendly and awesome. Great pricing on great products! Would Highly recommend!!!

  Edited 4 years ago

• Benjamin “Jj Sims-Olodukan” Hymer ★★★★★

  Dude ir my homey! Love this place. Best memorabilia in 100 mile radius. Highly recommended

  6 years ago

• Mike Green ★★★★★

  Very personal, and professional with a huge variety of products for every sports fan, oh yeah great prices too! Thanks agan!

  5 years ago